RE: The winners and losers of living in a decentralized community

You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The winners and losers of living in a decentralized community

View the full context

artemislives in OCD • 6 years ago

Great post @tarazkp - I think there is a HUGE divide between the witness community and the nerdy inner crowd, and the rest of us. I have asked several "leaders" in my steem world about how to choose witnesses, and simply been told to use them as proxy. That doesn't work for me.

The witnesses must take more responsibility for explaining who they are and what they stand for, to empower better and more responsible voting.

I'd love to see you taking some leadership to make this happen.

Much gratitude from a solo mom in Thailand who errs on the luddite side of town. :)

6 years ago in OCD by artemislives

0.00 BPC

1 vote

Sort:

Trending

[-]

tarazkp 6 years ago

Do you follow the witness accounts? On the witness link page many of them have links to their positions as witnesses too.

Don't proxy anyone you don't trust to vote for you. Ever.

0.00 BPC

[-]

artemislives 6 years ago

Question of the Day:: How to trust an anonymous steem person who doesn't even use a "real name"? LOL?? You are the first person in 2 years on steem to mention witness accounts - I had no idea. I'm hoping it is one short paragraph each in real-person speak.... LOL.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

tarazkp 6 years ago

In 2 years you haven't looked into how the system works?

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

artemislives 6 years ago (edited)

Only to a very basic level. The people I have asked have mostly blown me off. And the info in layperson's language is not easy to find. It may amuse you to know that I have 2 degrees - 1 in classical music & 1 in journalism 🤣 - after getting blown off for the 7th or 8th time, I voted for 5 or 6 witnesses who I knew NOTHING about & havent looked at it since. I curate for both @natiralmedicine & @ecotrain & it rarely comes up, although @riverflows is the most active on this issue of all. I think the witness end of steem has huge amounts of bridge building & communicating to do.... to the end point, foot-soldier users.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

tarazkp 6 years ago

A witness isn't a person, it is a machine (run by a person). This machine processes the blockchain and without them, nothing moves. They take a percentage of the reward pool as payment for this service and this is why the transactions on Steem are free, unlike most other blockchains.

A witness is part of a network of machines that cross-reference and verify each block to check it for consistency, to make sure that it is valid. They are spread all over the world and give what used to be, a decentralized structure.

Witnesses are (were) voted in by the community based on the stake of users and this creates the "top 20" who are considered "consensus" witnesses. It is these 20 who agree on the changes to the code, with 17/20 needing to upgrade their machines (agree) to the new version to create the change. They are also responsible for submitting (sometimes) and testing the new code that will be deployed.

The decentralized nature of this setup is that quite a few people need to agree in order to make any code change on the blockchain. Now that all witnesses are controlled by a single entity, it means the chain is centralized. This puts everyone at far greater risk as one "person" makes the decision on what is okay to implement or ban - without even a discussion.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

artemislives 6 years ago (edited)

Where were you when I signed up? 🤣

Seriously, the person-machine issue stops people voting. What does this witness believe & what is their vision? When people don't know that, and are also privvy to lots of public spats, downvotes etc etc.... they do.... nothing. Post & engage, if they stay.

There is far more to evolving steem than code. The best leaders lead in the language of the slowest person & the last in the line.

Thank you for patiently explaining. I came to steem mostly due to my work with unbankable refugees in Burma - the no censorship thing & decentralized matters. The tech end often leaves me feeling like a total ditz.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

tarazkp 6 years ago

There is (was) a decent mix of community witnesses (@ocd, @steempeak, @curie etc) and developer witness (@gtg, @themarkymark, @blocktrades, @therealwolf etc).

Not all coders are social animals, not all social witnesses can code.

As I see it, if one is going to invest into something, they best do their due diligence and have an understanding of what they are looking to hold.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

[-]

artemislives 6 years ago

I have only ever invested time into steem... earned all that I have.... & it was time I was already spwnding elsewhere. Many people, like me, dont come to steem as an investment. It's a tool only, for many.

0.00 BPC

1 vote

Show 1 more reply