RE: India Resists: Protests erupt all over the country against Unconstitutional Citizenship Amendment Act!

You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: India Resists: Protests erupt all over the country against Unconstitutional Citizenship Amendment Act!

hungryhustle in #india • 6 years ago

CAA and NRC in combo restrict only Muslims from getting the citizenship. That's where the problem lies!

Let's say you are a Muslim and fail to produce the documents that prove your citizenship, then you are
onsidered as an illegal immigrant. CAA restricts you to apply for citizenship because you are a muslim.

That's how the govt is playing with all the citizens. Moreover the financial impact of NRC and CAA is huge. That money could be used for doing things that matter.

For me, the argument that this law is based on religion is enough to understand that it is wrong.

6 years ago in #india by hungryhustle

0.00 BPC

Sort:

Trending

[-]

milaan 6 years ago

Let's say you are a Muslim and fail to produce the documents that prove your citizenship

How come? The illegal immigrants can vote with Voter ID, but they can not produce documents? What cheap this argument is?

I am sure you have not gone through the CAA act. That is why your article itself is falsifying and misleading. In India, there are more than 50 million immigrants from neighbouring countries. Are you trying to make India hub for illegal immigrants? If any muslim want to come to India and settle he can still apply for it, there is no restriction in that. But how can you justify the rohingyas and illegal immigrants who number is as high as 50 million. The actual figure will be even more than that.

Do you know that if you remain silent on illegal immigration, then it will continue to rise and those people will continue to exploit the resources which are meant for legal citizens. On the top of that they have voter card also, they are voting also. So indirectly you want illegal immgirants to vote in this country. Because you don't want CAA, means you want them to remain here..right? Without a law NRC can not be exercised. The Assam accord will still be in place and some confused people like you are spreading false information.

If I am muslim and I am not an intruder, then no one can take my citizenship. CAA does not affect that.

At least be a responsible blogger, I have no problem if you object to Govt policies. But it should be fact-based, not one-sided story.

0.00 BPC

[-]

hungryhustle 6 years ago

Btw, voter ID is not a proof your citizenship. Do you also consider people who are flood victims? They won't have any documents with them. And what about the financial implications of this law. What's the plan to do with those immigrants. Assam has 1.9 million people in the NRC. What's gonna happen to them? If anyone of them is Hindi, they are accepted. If someone is muslim, they are not. Also, govt. has wasted 1600 crores just to prove their point. And they failed in the most EPIC way.

Who is telling you to be silent for on Illegal Immigrants? You can talk about it. I am sure PM will hear ya! I am against it too. But CAA + NRC is way to make Muslims a poor minority in India. That's clear with every action they are taking. Now the media has been asked to not report pictures of Anti-CAA protests.

At least be a responsible blogger, I have no problem if you object to Govt policies. But it should be fact-based, not one-sided story.

I am being the most responsible blogger and the citizen of my country trying to show everyone the part which is being propagated as false narrative by paid media. I am telling you, I haven't mentioned any lies in the post. You can say it is one-sided story because the other side has been covered by many.

Also, I have read the bill many times that is why I could find the loopholes in the law. And everytime I read it, I could find many more. :))

Btw, BJP govt. is a fascist!!! Hitler 2019 got exposed.

0.00 BPC

[-]

milaan 6 years ago (edited)

Oh really again...you are getting too much prejudice.
What about the financial implication of damaging public property in violent protests.. any idea? I think you are conscious about financial implications, so you must have taken that into consideration too.

During electoral voting, an illegal migrant can vote is some way or the other, but for NRC, suddenly he becomes a flood victim?

CAA+NRC is the perfect dose to treat illegal immigrants.

Your own content is a part of the false narrative as it is not fact-based. Opinions can be different, but the fact will always remain the fact. If you can point out the loopholes in detail, then this debate can be productive, but personally I don't think this post is fact-oriented. When someone is so prejudiced to push the agenda in whatever possible means, then it is not going to be a fulfilling debate for democracy.

You can customize a label for it, but I m not gonna consumer of it.

Thank you....Good Bye....

0.00 BPC

[-]

hungryhustle 6 years ago

No use of arguing with a person who has made up his mind.

CAA + NRC will do the opposite. Now anyone can come and say "hi I am a Hindu" and they will be provided Indian Citizenship. What's the gurantee they are not going to do illegal activites that your "Illegal Immigrants" do in the country. Stop lying to yourself. And stop acussing me for being biased. I am giving you enough facts already. And my opinion is what I have told you based on the same facts.

And who told you to consume this? Mat karo bhai. Jo karna hai karo. Maine toh yeh international audience liye kiya tha post. Tum bhi kardo if you want to. And mention your facts or opinions. I will not go mad over your post and accuse you of spreading false information. I will just prove it if you do it.

Also, Don't talk about democracy when you are with the oppressor. And as I mentioned somewhere, I will reply to your comment with facts and only facts. Tab karlena discussion.

Regarding the violence, bhai kabhi samay mile toh google search karna ki violence ji hai na woh Police waalon ne bhi ki, BJP workers ne bhi and Opposition ne bhi. So... please.

Gooody good bye!

0.00 BPC